WARNING: This list will undermine my credibility as a film critic.
WORST ACTORS5th place: Lee Marvin - Great Marine; bad actor. No breadth; no depth.
4th place: William Hurt - BORING BORING BORING
3rd place: Ernest Borgnine - Ever since his first film role as Fatzo in
From Here to Eternity it's been down hill.
2nd place: Marlon Brando - Boorish, mumbling oaf.
1st place: Sean Penn - What a no nothing talent. If you saw his performance of Willie Stark in
All the Kings Men, you know what I'm talking about. Broderick Crawford he's not. (Best Actor 1949: Broderick Crawford for
All the King's Men)
BEST ACTORSI've been in a snit, brought on by the constraint of having to choose from The List of
previous Best Actor winners and the fact that
my first choice is not on the list. It ain't right. What we have here is a huge culture failure.
Here's the Baker's Dozen and notes to myself I started with to help me work through my despair.
1934: Clark Gable - Nothing effete about Clark Gable, baby.
1937: Spencer Tracy - It's been said "actors have noted that Tracy's work in 1930s films sometimes looks like a modern actor interacting with the more stylized and dated performances of everyone around him." Amazing, that was my exact reaction last week while watching
Captains Courageous, for the first time.
1940: James Stewart - After viewing
It's a Wonderful Life, President Harry S. Truman concluded, “If Bess and I had a son, we'd want him to be just like Jimmy Stewart.“ Well, there you go.
1941: Gary Cooper -
"...What we done in France we had to do. And some as done it, didn't come back. And that kind of thing ain't for buying and selling."Sargeant York, American hero.
1951: Humphrey Bogart -
"Well, I don't mind a reasonable amount of trouble..." Maltese Falcon
1953: William Holden: Could make you believe in the infinite possibilities of love and getting out of a POW camp.
1960: Burt Lancaster - "Brave, vigorous, handsome, and an actor of great range, Lancaster never yielded in his immaculate splendor, proud to be a movie actor. He was one of the great stars. Perhaps the last." — David Thomson
1964: Rex Harrison - A civilized man.
Professor Henry Higgins: Mother!
Mrs. Higgins: What is it, Henry? What's happened?
Professor Henry Higgins: [quietly] She's gone.
Mrs. Higgins: Well, of course, dear, what did you expect?
Professor Henry Higgins: What... what am I to do?
Mrs. Higgins: Do without, I suppose.
[pause]
Professor Henry Higgins: And so I shall! If the Higgins oxygen burns up her little lungs, let her seek some stuffiness that suits her. She's an owl sickened by a few days of my sunshine. Let her go, I can do without her. I can do without anyone. I have my own soul! My own spark of divine fire!
[storms outs]
1969: John Wayne - Imagine American film without John Wayne. Impossible. Neither complains nor seeks to be pitied; he will speak simply and truly of his trouble, without exaggerating its weight or bemoaning himself. If others pity him, he will accept their compassion patiently, unless they pity him for some ill he is not enduring, in which case he will say so with meekness, and abide in patience and truthfulness, combating his grief and not complaining of it.
[a de Sales quote]1983: Robert Duvall - I'll feel like I'm betraying Gus if I don't pick him.
1986: Paul Newman - remember Chance Wayne? Hud? Luke? The right stuff.
1989: Daniel Day-Lewis - "Hawkeye" - huge liquidating the enemy, coming to a woman's aid and hubba-hubba factor.
2000: Russell Crowe - only actor who ever showed up in one of my dreams. Yes, I surrendered completely to Capt. Jack Aubrey.
###
How I made my final selectionI imagined a film, an epic for our time, and asked myself who could deliver these lines, make it re
levant to the audience and inspire hope in humanity. The working title: "Tourbillon"; tagline -
Banality of Evil"No six-foot brownshirt, no police cell at midnight. Just Shirlene McGovern, an amiable enough bureaucrat, casually asking me about my political thoughts on behalf of the government. And she'll write up a report about it, and recommend that the government do this or that to me. Just going through checklists, you see ... a limp clerk who was just punching the clock. She had done it dozens of times before and will do it dozens of times again. In a way, that's more terrifying." **
Placed No. 5 - Russell Crowe
No. 4 - Burt Lancaster
No. 3 - Paul Newman
No. 2 - Spencer Tracy
No. 1 - Humphrey Bogart